Home
/
Literature
/
In This Excerpt from a Speech Before the Committee on the Judiciary of the U.S. House of Representatives in 1898 Alice Stone Blackwell

Question

In this excerpt from a speech before the Committee on the Judiciary of the U.S. House of Representatives in 1898 Alice Stone Blackwell advocates for women's suffrage. from The Indifference of Women 1 All this merely shows that human nature is conservative, and that it is fully as conservative in women as in men.The persons who take a strong interest in any reform are always comparatively few, whether among men or women, and they are habitually regarded with disfavor, even by those whom the proposed reform is to benefit. __ 2 Many changes for the better have been made during the last half century in the laws, written and unwritten, relating to women Everybody approves of these changes now, because they have become accomplished facts But not one of them would have been made to this day If it had been necessary to wait until the majority of women asked for it. The change now under discussion is to be judged on its merits In the light of history the indifference of most women and the opposition of a few must be taken as a matter of course. It has no more rational significance now than it has had in regard to each previous step of women's progress. (from "The Indifference of Women" by Alice Stone Blackwell) This question has two parts. Answer Part A,and then answer Part B. Part A What is the main claim the author makes in the passage? 1. The current proposal is too revolutionary to be approved. 2. Most people are afraid of change, even when it is necessary. 3. The people in opposition to the new policy are unreasonable. 4. Sometimes it is necessary to pass good but unpopular laws. Part B Which detail from the passage best supports the correct answer from Part A? 1. "All this merely shows that human nature is conservative.and that it is fully as conservative and that it is in men." (Paragraph 1) 2 "Evaruhnivannrnvac of these change

Solution

Expert Verified
4.7 (160 Votes)
Logan Professional ยท Tutor for 6 years

Answer

**Part A:**The correct answer is **4. Sometimes it is necessary to pass good but unpopular laws.** Blackwell argues that just because a majority of women don't actively support suffrage, it doesn't mean it's not a good or necessary change. She points out that many past reforms benefiting women were also initially unpopular.**Part B:**The detail that best supports this is **2. "Everybody approves of these changes now, because they have become accomplished facts. But not one of them would have been made to this day if it had been necessary to wait until the majority of women asked for it." (Paragraph 2)** This directly illustrates her point that positive changes have been made in the past despite a lack of widespread initial support, implying that the same could be true for suffrage.